THE MYTH OF THE THREE-COMPARTMENT CHRISTIAN (PART III)
“The Spiritual Dangers of “Spirit Versus Soul” Theology” Watchman Nee’s rigid trichotomy system is fraught with serious problems—and those problems are far from merely academic. When this tripartite view of human nature is turned into a method of spiritual guidance, it can profoundly distort the way Christians think about reason, emotion, revelation, discernment, and obedience. The believer is taught to imagine the inner person as a three-storey spiritual building: 1. the body occupies the ground floor, 2. the soul lives somewhere in the middle, 3. and the spirit enjoys privileged access to the penthouse where God supposedly communicates directly. The soul becomes the suspicious department. The mind, emotions, personality, and will are all treated as potentially obstructive. The spirit, meanwhile, is presented as the superior internal faculty through which divine knowledge supposedly arrives. The result is a theology that encourages Christians to distrust their God-given faculties whil...